Day 30 - Popular (Second) Opinion

Jan is in bed (the recliner) so I can finally get the results posted. We saw the doctor in Hermitage this afternoon for a second opinion. He was very nice and made a lot of sense. He actually talked to us in an intelligent way and didn't treat us as if we were stupid. He says the break is bad but is better than it could be.

This image identifies the different types of C2 odontoid fractures. Type I generally is only treated with a collar. Type II, where the whole tip is broken, fail to heal in 50% of cases.

Jan's break is a type III. A type III fracture is when the pin and the front of the vertebrae is broken off as a single piece. It is through the body of the vertebrae, which usually heal quite well. Her's is all the way down to the bottom. He says there is less than a 25% chance she'll need surgery. Much better than a type II.

The x-ray is a frame from Jan's ER CT scan. It is a slice viewed from the front. It goes farther through the body than the typical type III in the illustration. The doctor thinks that should lead to good union (healing) of the two parts.

Jan really liked him and wished we'd have gone to his hospital to begin with. I think it has something to do with him saying young people heal well.

He was shocked they didn't shave the rear pin sites, as indicated in the instructions for the vest. It keeps the chances of infection way down. He also didn't like the particular model of vest as they are more cumbersome than the ones he uses. Imagine that, $6,300 for the Yugo of halo-vests! You can buy a good used Honda for that kind of money.

In addition, he was surprised they didn't keep her 24 hours because you are supposed to check the screws in 24 hours. He said he would have kept her for a day for observation and then she and I would have been instructed on how to care for the pins. I guess that is the problem with teaching hospitals. If there is anything requiring surgery, she won't be having that at Bilkmore!

In the end, he says they did the proper things to protect her neck but they could have been a lot better about her treatment in general. He would have done much the same thing. He also said that it might have been treatable with just a collar but he would not have done it.

We probably could have gotten him to take the case as they asked us at check-in if we wanted that. The problem was his office hours are one day a week in Bowling Green and the next slot was in March! We could have continued to drive to Nashville to see him but he recommended we stay with Bilkmore. Jan was fine with that and I suppose I am, too. At least we have some valuable information and Bilkmore is the only place responsible should there be issues.

Now we come to Jan's next appointment at Bilkmore on Jan 23rd. The NP has ordered a CT scan to "make us feel better" about the treatment. The second opinion doctor says that the only reason to order a test is if you are going to do something or change treatment. He says there is no way they are going to take her out of the halo at six weeks so why do it. I agreed and Jan is considering canceling the appointment in favor of me going to the luncheon on the 23rd with my father and Tessa. She wants to push it to the next week with just an x-ray.

Instead, we are going to see if we can just get x-rays in Bowling Green to avoid the hassle at Bilkmore with the shuttle and the extended duration between imaging and NP appointment. For a 10:00 AM imaging appointment, we need to leave by 8:45 AM. The visit with the NP is at 12:30 PM and you just know she'll be running late. At the last appointment she was 30 minutes late and the visit lasted an hour and a half. Even if we make this one shorter, it will still be at least 2:00 PM before we are done and another hour to get home makes it an all day affair.